Monday, May 29, 2023
HomeFood NewsCookie Monster Cake (for Adorning Freshmen)

Cookie Monster Cake (for Adorning Freshmen)


Use this web page to learn to make a Cookie Monster cake, an lovable Sesame Avenue-themed do-it-yourself chocolate chip birthday cake. I like this adorning technique as a result of it’s fairly simple, even if you happen to’re a cake adorning newbie. You don’t want any fondant or particular molding substances for Cookie’s eyes and mouth. My video tutorial for Elmo Cake can be useful as a result of we’re primarily doing the identical factor, solely with out a nostril!

homemade decorated cookie monster cake on wooden cake stand.

For my oldest’s 2nd birthday, I made an Elmo cake, so it appeared very applicable—mandatory, even—to make a Cookie Monster cake for my youngest’s 2nd birthday! Her older sister loves Elmo, so Cookie Monster has naturally grow to be a favourite character round right here.

I’m not a complicated cake decorator. Whereas I’ve improved with devoted observe over time, you received’t see me making tremendous elaborate cake designs—a bare cake is extra my velocity! Nevertheless, this can be a surprisingly easy cake to brighten. The toughest half is the tedious job of piping all of Cookie Monster’s fur, so take just a few breaks to provide your hand a relaxation.

chocolate chip layer cake with blue frosting.

Chocolate Chips Galore Your Monsters Will Adore!

C is for cookies. And cake. And chocolate chips.

This cake is a lot enjoyable as a result of it contains chocolate chips inside, and it additionally contains chocolate chip cookies exterior. [Monster voice] COOOOKIEEES. I made a batch of mini chocolate chip cookies utilizing my recipe for mini M&M cookies, simply subbing mini chocolate chips for the mini M&Ms. These are excellent for including across the Cookie Monster cake, and in addition excellent for little cookie monsters to eat!

If you wish to make full-size cookies on your Cookie Monster cake to be “consuming,” you’ll be able to actually select any of your favourite cookie recipes. I made these chewy chocolate chip cookies. I feel he favored them. [Nom nom nom nom]

Make a 2-Layer Spherical Cake

The main target of this cake is the highest (versus the edges), so I opted for a shorter 2-layer cake. (Additionally, the taller the cake, the extra piping it is advisable do!) My 2-layer white cake recipe guarantees a tender and flavorful cake with the fluffiest texture. It’s all the time successful, particularly for birthday events. This time, I added mini chocolate chips to the cake batter, and all I’ve to say is YUM.

chocolate chip cake batter in glass bowl.
two round 9-inch chocolate chip cakes in cake pans.

Cool, then degree the truffles: The baked truffles can have a slight dome, so rigorously degree them off with a cake leveler or serrated knife. **Save the scraps as a result of they are going to be used for Cookie Monster’s eyes.**

two round 9-inch chocolate chip cakes leveled off.

Methods to Enhance Cookie Monster Cake

Now that you’ve your truffles prepared, let’s start to assemble and enhance.

  1. Make the Frosting: I used my favourite vanilla buttercream and elevated the ratio so I had extra frosting to work with. I extremely suggest following the frosting recipe under. Tint a lot of the frosting blue for Cookie Monster’s fur. Then tint some frosting black for his mouth and pupils and go away the remainder white for the cake’s filling. I like to recommend gel meals coloring, not liquid, to protect the consistency of the frosting. I used Americolor gel meals coloring in Royal Blue. Take note the frosting will dry barely darker than it seems if you’re mixing it. In the event you’d like to make use of pure meals coloring, I just like the model Supernatural; they’ve some powdered meals coloring that works effectively in frosting.
  2. Layer the Muffins: Layer the 2 truffles collectively in your cake stand, serving plate, or cake turntable and unfold 1 cup of untinted frosting between the 2.
  3. Add Crumb Coat: Apply a skinny layer of blue frosting across the sides and on prime of the cake. A bench scraper, icing spatula, and cake turntable are useful. The crumb coat creates a useful flat “base” of frosting for the piped fur ornament. Chill the crumb-coated cake as you make his eyes.
  4. Type Cookie Monster’s Eyes: Bear in mind the cake tops you leveled off? Crumble them up cake pops type. Combine with a bit of frosting and kind into 2 disc-like circles. Freeze till stable, about half-hour then coat in melted white chocolate. See in-depth directions on making Cookie’s eyes under.
  5. Add Mouth & Pipe Fur: With a small offset spatula, unfold a skinny layer of black on prime for Cookie Monster’s mouth, then use a toothpick to hint out its precise form. Now let’s start piping! You want a grass tip, akin to Wilton piping tip 233 or Wilton piping tip 234. To ensure that the fur to carry its piped form, the frosting should be comparatively thick, so be sure you observe my recipe under.
  6. Ending Touches: End the eyes (see under), and place them on prime of the cake. Add some cookies across the cake, and a damaged one in his mouth, and your Cookie Monster cake is completed!

Let’s see these adorning steps come collectively. Many of the frosting is tinted blue, then tint some black and go away the remainder untinted:

1 large bowl of blue frosting, 1 small bowl of black frosting, and 1 small bowl of white (untinted) frosting.

Layer the cooled and leveled-off truffles along with untinted buttercream between them. Use a number of the blue frosting to use a really skinny crumb coat:

blue crumb coated cake on wooden cake stand.

The crumb coated-cake should chill for at the very least half-hour to assist set the cake, so begin Cookie Monster’s eyes whilst you wait.

Methods to Make Cookie Monster’s Eyes

You don’t want something additional like rolled fondant or modeling chocolate to form Cookie Monster’s googly eyes. Slightly, merely use the scraps of cake that you simply leveled off, combined with a number of the white (untinted) buttercream frosting. Then we’ll coat them in melted white chocolate. We’re mainly making 2 cake pops, sans sticks. My style testers really thought the eyes have been exceptionally scrumptious, which is a bit of bit creepy, however there you could have it.

Shaping Tip: Solely add sufficient frosting to the cake crumbs to yield a semi-moist combination which you could form into his eyes. Type into 2 disc-like circles, about 2 inches in diameter, flattened barely. Freeze or refrigerate till stable, about half-hour.

chocolate chip cake crumbs mixed with frosting and shaped into flat cake pop discs.

After they’ve had an opportunity to solidify, soften the white chocolate. Chop up a bar of white chocolate (I just like the Ghirardelli sort, discovered within the baking aisle), and soften within the microwave in 20-second increments, stirring after every time. Dip the eyes into the melted white chocolate till fully coated, and raise out with a fork. Place on a sheet of parchment paper and chill within the fridge till the coating has set.

disc shaped cake pop dipped in white chocolate.

The eyes require 2 fast rounds of chilling, so circle again to the cake as you wait. Type the mouth and pipe the fur:

applying the blue frosting "fur" on cookie monster cake.

As soon as the white chocolate coating on Cookie’s eyes has set, pipe the black pupils with a spherical piping tip—bear in mind to make them googly— and gently press onto cake. Cookie Monster’s pupils are normally trying in reverse instructions; I assume that is an adaptation that helps him spot cookies irrespective of which method he’s dealing with. LOL

homemade decorated cookie monster cake on wooden cake stand.

And right here’s my Elmo Cake recipe, additionally excellent for cake adorning novices:

elmo cake

Beneficial Instruments for Cookie Monster Cake Ornament

At the moment’s publish is dropped at you by the letter C. 😉


clock clock iconcutlery cutlery iconflag flag iconfolder folder iconinstagram instagram iconpinterest pinterest iconfb fb iconprint print iconsquares squares iconcoronary heart coronary heart iconcoronary heart stable coronary heart stable icon


You’ll love this technique for a Cookie Monster cake as a result of it’s scrumptious AND comparatively simple, even if you happen to’re a cake adorning newbie. Evaluate the recipe and really helpful instruments earlier than starting.

Vanilla Buttercream

Cookie Monster’s Eyes

  1. Learn by way of the total instructions and watch my Elmo Cake video tutorial earlier than starting. (Similar technique right here, simply no nostril.) In the event you want to make the cake forward of time, learn my Make-Forward Directions under earlier than starting.
  2. Make the truffles: Preheat oven to 350°F (177°C). Grease two 9-inch cake pans, line with parchment paper (minimize 9-inch circles from parchment paper and place them within the greased pans), then grease the parchment paper. Parchment paper helps the truffles seamlessly launch from the pans.
  3. Whisk the cake flour, baking powder, baking soda, and salt collectively. Put aside.
  4. Utilizing a handheld or stand mixer fitted with a paddle or whisk attachment, beat the butter and sugar collectively on excessive velocity till creamed, about 2 minutes. Scrape down the edges and up the underside of the bowl with a rubber spatula as wanted. Add the egg whites, bitter cream, and vanilla. Beat on excessive velocity till totally mixed and combined, about 2 minutes. Scrape down the edges and up the underside of the bowl as wanted. Pour the dry substances into the bowl. Then with the mixer working on low, slowly pour within the milk. Don’t over-mix. You could must whisk all of it by hand to ensure there aren’t any lumps on the backside of the bowl. The batter can be barely thick.
  5. Toss mini chocolate chips with 1 Tablespoon of cake flour to coat them after which fold into the batter.
  6. Pour batter evenly into cake pans. Bake for round 25-26 minutes or till the truffles are baked by way of. To check for doneness, insert a toothpick into the middle of the cake. If it comes out clear, the cake is completed. Cool truffles within the pans set on a wire rack for half-hour, then take away the truffles and funky fully instantly on a wire rack. The truffles should be fully cool earlier than frosting and assembling.
  7. Make the buttercream: In a big bowl utilizing a handheld or stand mixer fitted with a paddle attachment, beat the butter on medium velocity till creamy, about 2 minutes. Add confectioners’ sugar, milk/cream, vanilla extract, and salt with the mixer working on low. Enhance to excessive velocity and beat for 3 full minutes. Style. Add a pinch of salt if frosting is method too candy. Frosting can be thick.
  8. Tint the frosting: Place 1 cup + 2 Tablespoons (about 1 heaping cup or 275g) of frosting right into a medium bowl. It will stay white/untinted and be used for the cake’s filling and to kind Cookie Monster’s eyes. Place 1/3 cup (about 85g) of frosting right into a small bowl. Stir in 3 drops of black gel meals coloring till it’s darkish grey. (Needless to say frosting dries darker.) Tint the remaining frosting blue utilizing about 4-5 huge drops of blue gel meals coloring. Tint till you’re happy with the colour. Bear in mind, frosting dries darker, and we’re going for lighter Cookie Monster blue, not darker Grover blue!
  9. Degree the truffles & add the crumb coat: Utilizing a big serrated knife, slice the domes off the cooled truffles (a semi-thin layer) to create a flat floor. Place tops right into a bowl to make use of in step 10. Place 1 cake layer in your cake stand, serving plate, or cake turntable. Unfold 1 cup (about 250g) of white untinted frosting all around the prime. (Reserve remaining white frosting for step 10.) Prime with 2nd layer. Unfold a skinny layer of blue frosting across the sides and prime of the cake. That is your crumb coat and must be a fairly skinny layer. An icing spatula and bench scraper are useful for this. Chill uncovered within the fridge or freezer for at the very least half-hour to assist set the crumb coat.
  10. In the meantime, form Cookie Monster’s eyes: Crumble the items of cake that you simply leveled off into crumbs. I simply use my fingers for this. Stir in 1 Tablespoon of white frosting. If the combination nonetheless appears fairly crumby and dry, add a bit of extra of the white frosting till you could have a moist combination which you could kind into shapes. Combination shouldn’t be overly moist. Type into two 2-inch discs. Easy them out as finest you’ll be able to. Place on a lined baking sheet and chill within the fridge or freezer for at the very least half-hour to set. As soon as they’re set, you’ll be able to easy out any bumps on the floor together with your fingers if wanted.
  11. In the meantime, pipe Cookie Monster’s fur: First, unfold a skinny layer of black frosting on the underside half of the highest of the cake. Use a small offset spatula to assist guarantee it’s completely easy. Reserve remaining black frosting. Utilizing a toothpick, hint/define Cookie’s mouth form throughout the black frosting. Use it as your information for piping his fur round it. Suit your piping bag with Wilton piping tip #233 (grass tip). Spoon some blue frosting inside. It’s tough to pipe this frosting if the bag is over-filled, so simply work with a bit of little bit of frosting within the bag at a time. Place the tip instantly on prime of the cake’s floor and apply stress to squeeze the frosting out of the tip. Rapidly raise the tip up whereas squeezing the frosting out. Pipe his fur all around the prime and sides of the cake. (The perimeters are elective, however if in case you have sufficient frosting, go for it!) It’s useful to rigorously tilt the cake stand/turntable so you’ll be able to extra simply pipe frosting on the edges. Set cake apart. You’ll be able to refrigerate uncovered if desired as you end Cookie’s eyes.
  12. Coat the eyes: Soften the white chocolate and oil collectively in a double boiler or the microwave. If utilizing the microwave: place the chopped chocolate and oil in a medium heat-proof bowl. Microwave for 20-second increments, stirring after every time, till fully melted and easy. Place one of many discs (eyes) into the white chocolate. Use a fork to assist totally coat it. Utilizing a fork, raise the disc (eye) out of the chocolate. Place again onto lined baking sheet. Repeat with 2nd disc (eye). Refrigerate or freeze for 20 minutes or till white chocolate has set.
  13. Ending touches: After the white chocolate units, suit your piping bag with Wilton tip #12 (spherical tip). Spoon some black frosting inside. Pipe Cookie Monster’s pupils onto the eyes—bear in mind to make them off-center and “googly”. Rigorously press the eyes on prime of the cake to kind Cookie’s face. If desired, add chocolate chip cookies across the cake and in his mouth, see Word.
  14. Serve & retailer: In the event you adorned the cake on a cake turntable, use a pair skinny spatulas (and a helper!) to rigorously raise the cake off the turntable and onto a cake stand, server, or cake provider base. I really like to make use of a cake provider to cowl and retailer my truffles within the fridge.
  15. Cowl leftover cake tightly and retailer within the fridge for as much as 5 days.


  1. Make-Forward Directions: You’ll be able to put together the cake layers forward of time. Wrap the person baked and cooled cake layers tightly and refrigerate for as much as 2 days. It’s also possible to assemble the cake with Cookie Monster’s mouth & piped fur 2 days forward of time, too. It’s also possible to make, coat in white chocolate, cowl, and refrigerate his eyes forward of time as effectively. Don’t place on cake till the day of serving because the blue from Cookie’s fur could smear onto the eyes. Pipe his pupils the day of serving as a result of the black can smear down onto his eyes if refrigerated forward of time. It did this for me, so I simply rigorously wiped it off.
  2. Freezing Directions: Freeze the cake layers for as much as 3 months. See Methods to Freeze Cake for directions. Convey cake layers to room temperature, then proceed with step 7.
  3. Beneficial Instruments: KitchenAid Stand Mixer | 9-inch Cake Pans | Grass TipSpherical Tip | Piping Luggage (disposable or reusable) | Toothpick | Cake Turntable | Small Offset Spatula | Giant Icing Spatula | Bench Scraper | Blue & Black Gel Meals Coloring
  4. Complete Milk & Bitter Cream: Complete milk and bitter cream are strongly really helpful for one of the best style and texture. A full fats plain yogurt would work as a substitute, although the cake might not be as gentle. Similar goes with a decrease fats milk.
  5. White Chocolate: Use actual white chocolate to coat the eyes. You need to use high-quality white chocolate chips if wanted (I want Ghirardelli model), however I like to recommend utilizing pure chocolate baking bars. You will discover them proper subsequent to the chocolate chips within the baking aisle. They’re bought in 4-ounce (113g) bars. I like Bakers or Ghirardelli manufacturers. It’s also possible to use 4 ounces of white sweet melts.
  6. Meals Coloring: Use gel, not liquid, meals coloring. I like to recommend Americolor model in royal blue and black. In the event you’d like to make use of pure meals coloring, I just like the model Supernatural; they’ve some powdered meals coloring that works effectively in frosting.
  7. Serving: This cake serves about 12 folks, however I served almost 20 folks (10 adults and 10 children). Minimize skinny slices.
  8. Cookies for Garnish: Use this recipe for mini M&M cookies, swapping mini chocolate chips for the mini M&Ms. For full-size cookies, use this recipe for chocolate chip cookies.

Key phrases: cookie monster cake




Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular

Recent Comments